After we tried to upgrade our project to use DAML SDK 1.0, we got the following error in an integration test:
INVALID_ARGUMENT: Disputed: recreated and original transaction mismatch
What is such an error and what may cause it given that the same integration test worked with previous SDK versions?
See the following PR that does the upgrade and fixes compilation but fails with the above error :
The error is a validation error. Ie the validation code ādisputesā the submitted transaction. That shouldnāt be possible in the Sandbox except with contract keys, which you donāt use, so it suggests a bug. Weāll need to investigate.
Could you provide the full error message please? It should contain both the expected and the recreated transaction and give us a better idea of what might have gone wrong. Thank you.
You can see the error if you click on the circle CI link on the github PR https://circleci.com/gh/digital-asset/ex-bond-issuance/765?utm_campaign=vcs-integration-link&utm_medium=referral&utm_source=github-build-link
Copying the relevant part here:
io.grpc.StatusRuntimeException: INVALID_ARGUMENT: Disputed: recreated and original transaction mismatch GenTransaction(Map(NodeId(0) -> NodeExercises(None,AbsoluteContractId(008ab00113b981785d9db1aeb1757d2b28024bc02cac02a7ebab8b29d88593ee07),d20982a667182bce8eb61395fb1c30e5c8ad5f20af14ad518c4a58cccddde1a5:DA.RefApps.Bond.Auction:BidderParticipation,BidderParticipation_PlaceBid,None,false,Set(Bank1),VersionedValue(ValueVersion(6),ValueRecord(Some(d20982a667182bce8eb61395fb1c30e5c8ad5f20af14ad518c4a58cccddde1a5:DA.RefApps.Bond.Auction:BidderParticipation_PlaceBid),ImmArray((Some(price),ValueNumeric(42.0000000000)),(Some(quantity),ValueInt64(200000))))),Set(AuctionAgent, Bank1, Issuer, Regulator),Set(AuctionAgent, Issuer),Set(Bank1),ImmArray(NodeId(1)),Some(VersionedValue(ValueVersion(6),ValueContractId(AbsoluteContractId(0065f8ddbafbbc0b2d7b6394ff8dbca0e83d111e6f3a8ec6ef677de3000f939f21)))),None), NodeId(1) -> NodeCreate(None,AbsoluteContractId(0065f8ddbafbbc0b2d7b6394ff8dbca0e83d111e6f3a8ec6ef677de3000f939f21),ContractInst(d20982a667182bce8eb61395fb1c30e5c8ad5f20af14ad518c4a58cccddde1a5:DA.RefApps.Bond.Auction:PlaceBidBotTrigger,VersionedValue(ValueVersion(6),ValueRecord(Some(d20982a667182bce8eb61395fb1c30e5c8ad5f20af14ad518c4a58cccddde1a5:DA.RefApps.Bond.Auction:PlaceBidBotTrigger),ImmArray((Some(cashAssetId),ValueRecord(Some(af4883c0b0a58101f424e475221f905c7af77a363841054a36ccd9b34d0468aa:DA.Finance.Types:Id),ImmArray((Some(signatories),ValueRecord(Some(ed2beae6b3bc8a8804ef43a7add61c87689c18e7b4a2ed45ec2f866df40d16f0:DA.Next.Set:Set),ImmArray((Some(textMap),ValueTextMap(SortedLookupList((CentralBank,ValueUnit))))))),(Some(label),ValueText(USD)),(Some(version),ValueInt64(0))))),(Some(cashProvider),ValueParty(CentralBank)),(Some(bondProvider),ValueParty(CSD)),(Some(bidder),ValueParty(Bank1)),(Some(auctionAgent),ValueParty(AuctionAgent)),(Some(issuer),ValueParty(Issuer)),(Some(bidData),ValueRecord(Some(d20982a667182bce8eb61395fb1c30e5c8ad5f20af14ad518c4a58cccddde1a5:DA.RefApps.Bond.Auction:BidData),ImmArray((Some(price),ValueNumeric(42.0000000000)),(Some(quantity),ValueInt64(200000)),(Some(submissionTime),ValueTimestamp(2020-04-21T19:42:05.610248Z))))),(Some(auctionName),ValueText(testAuction)),(Some(bondAssetId),ValueRecord(Some(af4883c0b0a58101f424e475221f905c7af77a363841054a36ccd9b34d0468aa:DA.Finance.Types:Id),ImmArray((Some(signatories),ValueRecord(Some(ed2beae6b3bc8a8804ef43a7add61c87689c18e7b4a2ed45ec2f866df40d16f0:DA.Next.Set:Set),ImmArray((Some(textMap),ValueTextMap(SortedLookupList((CSD,ValueUnit))))))),(Some(label),ValueText(BOND-007)),(Some(version),ValueInt64(0))))),(Some(regulators),ValueList(FrontStack(ValueParty(Regulator))))))),),None,Set(AuctionAgent, Bank1),Set(AuctionAgent, Bank1, Regulator),None)),ImmArray(NodeId(0))) expected, but GenTransaction(Map(NodeId(0) -> NodeExercises(Some(Hash(27a958b96a137611696bb7e8b51fdb4dd8e4d27e3fad7beca3620d0789b5f2d3)),AbsoluteContractId(008ab00113b981785d9db1aeb1757d2b28024bc02cac02a7ebab8b29d88593ee07),d20982a667182bce8eb61395fb1c30e5c8ad5f20af14ad518c4a58cccddde1a5:DA.RefApps.Bond.Auction:BidderParticipation,BidderParticipation_PlaceBid,Some(Location(ed2beae6b3bc8a8804ef43a7add61c87689c18e7b4a2ed45ec2f866df40d16f0,DA.Internal.Prelude,$u002b$u002b,(380,25),(380,27))),false,TreeSet(Bank1),VersionedValue(ValueVersion(6),ValueRecord(Some(d20982a667182bce8eb61395fb1c30e5c8ad5f20af14ad518c4a58cccddde1a5:DA.RefApps.Bond.Auction:BidderParticipation_PlaceBid),ImmArray((Some(price),ValueNumeric(42.0000000000)),(Some(quantity),ValueInt64(200000))))),TreeSet(AuctionAgent, Bank1, Issuer, Regulator),TreeSet(AuctionAgent, Issuer),TreeSet(Bank1),ImmArray(NodeId(1)),Some(VersionedValue(ValueVersion(6),ValueContractId(AbsoluteContractId(0065f8ddbafbbc0b2d7b6394ff8dbca0e83d111e6f3a8ec6ef677de3000f939f21)))),None), NodeId(1) -> NodeCreate(Some(Hash(89ae0238bc076b179aced331e1309efc04b51382c27c615b84f19ec956b94bf5)),AbsoluteContractId(0065f8ddbafbbc0b2d7b6394ff8dbca0e83d111e6f3a8ec6ef677de3000f939f21),ContractInst(d20982a667182bce8eb61395fb1c30e5c8ad5f20af14ad518c4a58cccddde1a5:DA.RefApps.Bond.Auction:PlaceBidBotTrigger,VersionedValue(ValueVersion(6),ValueRecord(Some(d20982a667182bce8eb61395fb1c30e5c8ad5f20af14ad518c4a58cccddde1a5:DA.RefApps.Bond.Auction:PlaceBidBotTrigger),ImmArray((Some(cashAssetId),ValueRecord(Some(af4883c0b0a58101f424e475221f905c7af77a363841054a36ccd9b34d0468aa:DA.Finance.Types:Id),ImmArray((Some(signatories),ValueRecord(Some(ed2beae6b3bc8a8804ef43a7add61c87689c18e7b4a2ed45ec2f866df40d16f0:DA.Next.Set:Set),ImmArray((Some(textMap),ValueTextMap(SortedLookupList((CentralBank,ValueUnit))))))),(Some(label),ValueText(USD)),(Some(version),ValueInt64(0))))),(Some(cashProvider),ValueParty(CentralBank)),(Some(bondProvider),ValueParty(CSD)),(Some(bidder),ValueParty(Bank1)),(Some(auctionAgent),ValueParty(AuctionAgent)),(Some(issuer),ValueParty(Issuer)),(Some(bidData),ValueRecord(Some(d20982a667182bce8eb61395fb1c30e5c8ad5f20af14ad518c4a58cccddde1a5:DA.RefApps.Bond.Auction:BidData),ImmArray((Some(price),ValueNumeric(42.0000000000)),(Some(quantity),ValueInt64(200000)),(Some(submissionTime),ValueTimestamp(2020-04-21T19:42:35.212276Z))))),(Some(auctionName),ValueText(testAuction)),(Some(bondAssetId),ValueRecord(Some(af4883c0b0a58101f424e475221f905c7af77a363841054a36ccd9b34d0468aa:DA.Finance.Types:Id),ImmArray((Some(signatories),ValueRecord(Some(ed2beae6b3bc8a8804ef43a7add61c87689c18e7b4a2ed45ec2f866df40d16f0:DA.Next.Set:Set),ImmArray((Some(textMap),ValueTextMap(SortedLookupList((CSD,ValueUnit))))))),(Some(label),ValueText(BOND-007)),(Some(version),ValueInt64(0))))),(Some(regulators),ValueList(FrontStack(ValueParty(Regulator))))))),),Some(Location(ed2beae6b3bc8a8804ef43a7add61c87689c18e7b4a2ed45ec2f866df40d16f0,DA.Internal.Prelude,$u002b$u002b,(380,25),(380,27))),TreeSet(AuctionAgent, Bank1),TreeSet(AuctionAgent, Bank1, Regulator),None)),ImmArray(NodeId(0))) is recreated
at com.digitalasset.refapps.bondissuance.BondIssuanceIT.testFullWorkflow(BondIssuanceIT.java:139)
@gaborh: I found an issue in your SDK upgrade PR and posted a comment there. You are setting the min_ledger_time_rel field when thereās actually no need for it. I suspect this is an artifact from the LET/MRT settings that was used previously. For the purpose of your PR, you can simply set the parameter to Optional.empty().
However, this surfaced a bug in the ledger time handling, so thanks for that. We will add a test case together with a fix.